Chimney Hill Apartments
How We Increased NOI by 185% & Created $4.75 Million in Value
58 units
Projected Net Equity Multiple: 8.5x
(two cash out refinancings + unrealized gains)*
Hold Period: 20+ years
Simple Per Annum Return (to date): 23.85%*
NCREIF Benchmark Return Comparison: 7.8%
The Opportunity
Chimney Hill is a uniquely designed and well-built property, but it was in a weak, dislocated market.
The upside was that Chimney Hill was strategically located along an obvious growth corridor with good access to transportation. It also had large, competitive floor plans with lots of natural light, and excellent construction quality.
The property also suffered from under investment & deferred maintenance, which further weakened rents and occupancy. The property was listed for sale, but few buyers were willing to bet on the recovery of this market. Lenders were also very conservative, further reducing liquidity for this asset. These conditions allowed us to negotiate very favorable acquisition terms for Chimney Hill and almost completely cover our downside.
The Execution
Despite the scarcity of lenders, our capital markets expertise enabled us to place our 10-year, fixed-rate acquisition debt directly with a CMBS conduit at full leverage with no recourse. This increased our return on equity and lowered our risk related to recourse and personal guarantees.
After closing, we increased occupancy from 85% to 95% almost immediately with more intensive management. We then began selective interior upgrades to improve rents, and we reduced operating expenses through technology enhancements. These changes drove NOI growth to such an extent that we were able to refinance our acquisition debt with new non-recourse FNMA agency debt. This capital event was sufficient to return 100% of initial equity capital plus a significant multiple.
In addition, the local market strengthened, and clear indications of recovery emerged, including a ground up $200 million development that will include a 3,000 seat event center, premium hotels, shopping, dining, and housing.
In 2023, we refinanced yet again, and this refinancing returned yet another significant multiple of capital. We continue to own this asset today, and we see new opportunities to generate NOI growth from additional interior and exterior upgrades, general market growth, and the introduction of new operational efficiencies through technology. To date, Chimney Hill has generated a 23.85% simple per annum return vs. the NCREIF benchmark return of 7.8%*.
We are now completing an exciting exterior renovation of Chimney Hill, including full siding replacement in a bold new design that matches the market recovery. We are also adding new smart home features, including video intercom security systems, smart locks and dedicated property-wide 100% fiber optic managed wifi. These technology investments will allow us to enhance the resident experience and further optimize operational efficiencies for the next phase of NOI growth.
What This Means For Investors
- Proven ability to identity assets with high potential for strong long term cash flow and valuation growth
- Demonstrated ability to execute complex, multi-year value-add strategies
- Highly capable property management and asset management teams
- Repeatability and replicability
*Unaudited. Past performance is no guarantee of future performance.